Cannot traceroute from SCO through LINUX but from windows 2000

[Chalawal Maliwan]

W2K (A) --------->
LINUX GATEWAY (C) --------> The
world
OSR5 (B) --------->X

From the illustration above,

(A) I could do both "ping" and "tracert" to the world from windows
2000.
(B) I could not "traceroute" from OSR5 to the world but I could "ping"
the world from OSR5.

What could cause this problem, as I know both "traceroute" and "ping"
are using icmp.


Thanks for any help,
Chalawal

[Whoever]

On 20 Aug 2003, Chalawal Maliwan wrote:

> W2K (A) --------->
> LINUX GATEWAY (C) --------> The
> world
> OSR5 (B) --------->X
>
> From the illustration above,
>
> (A) I could do both "ping" and "tracert" to the world from windows
> 2000.
> (B) I could not "traceroute" from OSR5 to the world but I could "ping"
> the world from OSR5.
>
> What could cause this problem, as I know both "traceroute" and "ping"
> are using icmp.
>

This is not true. Traceroute normally sends out UDP packets with a high
destination port number) and increasing TTLs. It then picks up the
resulting icmp replies (ttl exceeded).

[Chalawal Maliwan]

>

> Unreadable mess. Repackage for 80 column screens.

Sorry, I repackaged it again. please see below

OSR5 ->
LINUX (2IPs LAN+WAN) --> Internet
W2K ->

- I can ping the internet but not traceroute from OSR5
- I can do both ping and tracert from W2K to the Internet

> Can you traceroute from OSR5 to any of the local machines by IP
> address? If not, what error message do you get?
>

Yes, to others but not the LINUX LAN IP

> Can you traceroute from oSR5 to any of the local machines by machine
> name? If you can traceroute by IP, but not by machine name, check the
> contents of /etc/hosts and /etc/resolv.conf for name lookup problems.

Yes, but not the LINUX's machine name

> If both the above work, can you traceroute by IP address to any
> machine on the internet? Pick one that actually returns ICMP packets.
> If not, what error message do you get? If not, your Linux gateway is
> doing something to the packets.

No, so my linux is doing something to the package when the source IP
is from the OSR5 only?

> If you can traceroute to the internet by IP address, try it by name.
> If the name does not work, but the IP address does, your Linux gateway
> is doing something to DNS lookups.

The traceroute using name is given below

#traceroute mail.yahoo.com
traceroute to login.yahoo.akadns.net (66.163.171.128), 30 hops max, 40
byte pack
ets
1 * * *
2 * * *
3 * * *
4 * * *
5 * * *
........

Thanks for your kind help,

Chalawal

[Jeff Liebermann]

On 21 Aug 2003 16:35:03 -0700, [email]chalawal@hotmail.com[/email] (Chalawal Maliwan)
wrote:

>- I can ping the internet but not traceroute from OSR5
>- I can do both ping and tracert from W2K to the Internet
>

>> Can you traceroute from OSR5 to any of the local machines by IP
>> address? If not, what error message do you get?
>>

>Yes, to others but not the LINUX LAN IP

Since you need to go *THROUGH* the Linux gateway to get to the
internet, this is the first problem that needs to be solved. Let's
concentrate on this one. I forgot to ask:
Can you ping the Linux box from the OSR5 machine by IP address?
My guess(tm) is that you cannot.

Since the W2K box can probably (not sure) ping the Linux box, I'll
assume that the Linux box is properly configured. More questions:

Is the Linux box and OSR5 box on the same Class C subnet?
Are the subnet masks the same on all machines? (i.e. 255.255.255.0)
You can display those on OSR5 with:
ifconfig -a
or perhaps:
ifconfig net0
The "ffffff00" means 255.255.255.0

The W2K box will show the IP's in a "CMD" window with:
ipconfig
or:
ipconfig -a

The unspecified Linux mutation box will probably use:
/sbin/ifconfig

Compare the numbers, Class C IP blocks, and netmasks.

>> Can you traceroute from oSR5 to any of the local machines by machine
>> name? If you can traceroute by IP, but not by machine name, check the
>> contents of /etc/hosts and /etc/resolv.conf for name lookup problems.

>
>Yes, but not the LINUX's machine name

That's understandable since you also cannot traceroute to the Linux
box by IP address. If the IP address does not work, the name will
also not work. Let's ignore the DNS (name service) issues for now and
do everything with IP addresses. Once that is working, we may be
lucky and have the DNS lookups working.

>> If both the above work, can you traceroute by IP address to any
>> machine on the internet? Pick one that actually returns ICMP packets.
>> If not, what error message do you get? If not, your Linux gateway is
>> doing something to the packets.

>
>No, so my linux is doing something to the package when the source IP
>is from the OSR5 only?

No. I don't think so. Since you cannot DIRECTLY ping the Linux box,
you cannot route to it, send packets through it, or expect anything to
be returned from a remote internet host. Concentrate on why the OSR5
box cannot traceroute (or possibly cannot ping) the Linux box.


--
# Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D Santa Cruz CA 95060
# 831.336.2558 voice [url]http://www.LearnByDestroying.com[/url]
# [email]jeffl@comix.santa-cruz.ca.us[/email]
# 831.421.6491 digital_pager [email]jeffl@cruzio.com[/email] AE6KS

[Whoever]

On 21 Aug 2003, Chalawal Maliwan wrote:

> >
> > Unreadable mess. Repackage for 80 column screens.

>
> Sorry, I repackaged it again. please see below
>
> OSR5 ->
> LINUX (2IPs LAN+WAN) --> Internet
> W2K ->
>
> - I can ping the internet but not traceroute from OSR5
> - I can do both ping and tracert from W2K to the Internet
>

> > Can you traceroute from OSR5 to any of the local machines by IP
> > address? If not, what error message do you get?
> >

> Yes, to others but not the LINUX LAN IP
>

OK, I think I have the solution for you.

Microsoft tracert uses outgoing icmp packets. Most *nix systems use
outgoing UDP packets, with port numbers starting from 33434 and
incremented from there.

Perhaps the firewall on the Linux box is dropping the UDP traceroute
packets?

Try using tcpdump and see what traffic is on the LAN interface of the
Linux box when:
1. You do a tracert from the W2K box
2. When you do a traceroute from the OSR5 box.

Note there are also traceroute implementations that use TCP packets.

[Chalawal Maliwan]

> Since you need to go *THROUGH* the Linux gateway to get to the

> internet, this is the first problem that needs to be solved. Let's
> concentrate on this one. I forgot to ask:
> Can you ping the Linux box from the OSR5 machine by IP address?
> My guess(tm) is that you cannot.

I can

>
> Since the W2K box can probably (not sure) ping the Linux box, I'll
> assume that the Linux box is properly configured. More questions:
>
> Is the Linux box and OSR5 box on the same Class C subnet?
> Are the subnet masks the same on all machines? (i.e. 255.255.255.0)

They are all on the same class C subnet

>
> No. I don't think so. Since you cannot DIRECTLY ping the Linux box,
> you cannot route to it, send packets through it, or expect anything to
> be returned from a remote internet host. Concentrate on why the OSR5
> box cannot traceroute (or possibly cannot ping) the Linux box.

OSR5 can directly ping the LINUX box (Both LAN and WAN IPs) but cannot
traceroute through it

Thanks for your kind advise,

Chalawal

[Jeff Liebermann]

On 22 Aug 2003 18:55:35 -0700, [email]chalawal@hotmail.com[/email] (Chalawal Maliwan)
wrote:

>> Since you need to go *THROUGH* the Linux gateway to get to the
>> internet, this is the first problem that needs to be solved. Let's
>> concentrate on this one. I forgot to ask:
>> Can you ping the Linux box from the OSR5 machine by IP address?
>> My guess(tm) is that you cannot.

>
>I can

So much for that guess. That might mean that the Linux box is either
not responding to UDP/ICMP traceroute packets possibly because you
have some kind of misconfigured firewall (IPChains, IPFilters) running
on the Linux LAN port. Without detailed knowledge of the Linux
configuration I have no way to determine exactly what is happening.

Dumb questions:
Can the OSR5 box ping the W2K box by IP address?
Can it traceroute the W2K box by IP address?

>OSR5 can directly ping the LINUX box (Both LAN and WAN IPs) but cannot
>traceroute through it

The real mystery is why the W2K tracert works and the OSR5 traceroute
does not. One would therefore suspect the OSR5 box. However, there
is no guarantee that the OSR5 box uses exactly the same traceroute
mechanism as W2K.

I'm not sure what to do next. Packet sniffing is my favorite tool.
Without additional information (exact error messages, version numbers,
Linux incantation, IP addresses, etc), there's not much that I can do
from here. Sorry.


--
# Jeff Liebermann 150 Felker St #D Santa Cruz CA 95060
# 831.336.2558 voice [url]http://www.LearnByDestroying.com[/url]
# [email]jeffl@comix.santa-cruz.ca.us[/email]
# 831.421.6491 digital_pager [email]jeffl@cruzio.com[/email] AE6KS

[Bela Lubkin]

Chalawal Maliwan wrote:

[quoting Jeff Liebermann:]

> > Since you need to go *THROUGH* the Linux gateway to get to the
> > internet, this is the first problem that needs to be solved. Let's
> > concentrate on this one. I forgot to ask:
> > Can you ping the Linux box from the OSR5 machine by IP address?
> > My guess(tm) is that you cannot.

>
> I can
>

> > Since the W2K box can probably (not sure) ping the Linux box, I'll
> > assume that the Linux box is properly configured. More questions:
> >
> > Is the Linux box and OSR5 box on the same Class C subnet?
> > Are the subnet masks the same on all machines? (i.e. 255.255.255.0)

>
> They are all on the same class C subnet
>

> > No. I don't think so. Since you cannot DIRECTLY ping the Linux box,
> > you cannot route to it, send packets through it, or expect anything to
> > be returned from a remote internet host. Concentrate on why the OSR5
> > box cannot traceroute (or possibly cannot ping) the Linux box.

>
> OSR5 can directly ping the LINUX box (Both LAN and WAN IPs) but cannot
> traceroute through it

I haven't seen anyone ask you what happens if you `traceroute -n` from
the OSR5 box. DNS issues can cause `traceroute` to appear to be failing
when in fact it is succeeding, but getting hung up looking for the name
of the machine whose reply packet it received.

I know you don't think you have DNS issues, but try it anyway.

>Bela<