CustomValidator bug?

[George Ter-Saakov]

Hi.

I am fighting the CustomValidator strange behavior for second day already.
I created some test project which is only to reproduce the problem.

1. I created UserControl which has an only a Custom Validator
2. in UserControl::Page_Load i set
CustomValidator1.IsValid = false;

3. I insert the User Control into the page and have a submit button there.


So when i run the project it shows me errors from CustomValidator (because
IsValid set to false)
But when i click submit button there is no error shown and Page.IsValid
returns true.


Am i missing something? Where should i set CustomValidator1.IsValid = false;
so the Page.IsValid would be set to false as well?


Thanks.
George.

[Hans Kesting]

"George Ter-Saakov" <we@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:ugr99JFUDHA.1552@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

> Hi.
>
> I am fighting the CustomValidator strange behavior for second day already.
> I created some test project which is only to reproduce the problem.
>
> 1. I created UserControl which has an only a Custom Validator
> 2. in UserControl::Page_Load i set
> CustomValidator1.IsValid = false;
>
> 3. I insert the User Control into the page and have a submit button there.
>
>
> So when i run the project it shows me errors from CustomValidator (because
> IsValid set to false)
> But when i click submit button there is no error shown and Page.IsValid
> returns true.
>
>
> Am i missing something? Where should i set CustomValidator1.IsValid =

false;

> so the Page.IsValid would be set to false as well?
>
>
> Thanks.
> George.
>
>

To implement a CustomValidator you need to handle the ServerValidate event.


private void CustomValidator1_ServerValidate(object source,
System.Web.UI.WebControls.ServerValidateEventArgs args)
{
args.IsValid = false;
}


Hans Kesting

[George Ter-Saakov]

Got to the bottom of it.
It turned out that I must provide handler CustomValidator.ServerValidate and
set args.IsValid = false in it.

Otherwise the IsValid is reset to true.

Which is not very good design. I would say if ServerValidate event is not
handled then IsValid must stay as is.

Thanks.
George.


"George Ter-Saakov" <we@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:ugr99JFUDHA.1552@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl...

> Hi.
>
> I am fighting the CustomValidator strange behavior for second day already.
> I created some test project which is only to reproduce the problem.
>
> 1. I created UserControl which has an only a Custom Validator
> 2. in UserControl::Page_Load i set
> CustomValidator1.IsValid = false;
>
> 3. I insert the User Control into the page and have a submit button there.
>
>
> So when i run the project it shows me errors from CustomValidator (because
> IsValid set to false)
> But when i click submit button there is no error shown and Page.IsValid
> returns true.
>
>
> Am i missing something? Where should i set CustomValidator1.IsValid =

false;

> so the Page.IsValid would be set to false as well?
>
>
> Thanks.
> George.
>
>