Perl way to do PHP includes?

[Garry Heaton]

Are the following Perl/PHP methods roughly equivalent in function and
efficiencey?

1. use Perl_package;
require_once(file.php);

2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
include(file.php);

I'm trying to determine whether Perl/CGI.pm (no Embperl, Mason etc.) is
sufficient for converting PHP scripts without incurring serious inefficiencies.

Regards

Garry Heaton

[Eric Schwartz]

Garry Heaton <none@none.com> writes:

> Are the following Perl/PHP methods roughly equivalent in function and
> efficiencey?
>
> 1. use Perl_package;
> require_once(file.php);

Vaguely. You should read the perlmod docs ('perldoc perlmod') to find
out exactly how this works. PHP just reads in the file and defines
all the functions in it in the global namespace; Perl lets you be more
fine-grained if you choose.

> 2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
> include(file.php);

Not even close. Did you read the Perl docs for open() to see what it
does?

> I'm trying to determine whether Perl/CGI.pm (no Embperl, Mason etc.) is
> sufficient for converting PHP scripts without incurring serious inefficiencies.

The question to be sure you've answered is why convert them if they're
working now? Assuming you have a good reason, then it's best to have
a good understanding of both languages. perldoc perlbook for more
details about learning Perl.

-=Eric
--
Come to think of it, there are already a million monkeys on a million
typewriters, and Usenet is NOTHING like Shakespeare.
-- Blair Houghton.

[Garry Heaton]

Eric Schwartz wrote:

> Garry Heaton <none@none.com> writes:
>

>>Are the following Perl/PHP methods roughly equivalent in function and
>>efficiencey?
>>
>>1. use Perl_package;
>> require_once(file.php);

>
>
> Vaguely. You should read the perlmod docs ('perldoc perlmod') to find
> out exactly how this works. PHP just reads in the file and defines
> all the functions in it in the global namespace; Perl lets you be more
> fine-grained if you choose.
>
>

>>2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
>> include(file.php);

>
>
> Not even close. Did you read the Perl docs for open() to see what it
> does?
>
>

>>I'm trying to determine whether Perl/CGI.pm (no Embperl, Mason etc.) is
>>sufficient for converting PHP scripts without incurring serious inefficiencies.

>
>
> The question to be sure you've answered is why convert them if they're
> working now? Assuming you have a good reason, then it's best to have
> a good understanding of both languages. perldoc perlbook for more
> details about learning Perl.
>
> -=Eric

Sorry, should have followed-up:

2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
while (<FILE>) {
print;
};

Garry

[Garry Heaton]

Garry Heaton wrote:

> Eric Schwartz wrote:
>

>>Garry Heaton <none@none.com> writes:
>>
>>

>>>Are the following Perl/PHP methods roughly equivalent in function and
>>>efficiencey?
>>>
>>>1. use Perl_package;
>>> require_once(file.php);

>>
>>
>>Vaguely. You should read the perlmod docs ('perldoc perlmod') to find
>>out exactly how this works. PHP just reads in the file and defines
>>all the functions in it in the global namespace; Perl lets you be more
>>fine-grained if you choose.
>>
>>
>>

>>>2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
>>> include(file.php);

>>
>>
>>Not even close. Did you read the Perl docs for open() to see what it
>>does?
>>
>>
>>

>>>I'm trying to determine whether Perl/CGI.pm (no Embperl, Mason etc.) is
>>>sufficient for converting PHP scripts without incurring serious inefficiencies.

>>
>>
>>The question to be sure you've answered is why convert them if they're
>>working now? Assuming you have a good reason, then it's best to have
>>a good understanding of both languages. perldoc perlbook for more
>>details about learning Perl.
>>
>>-=Eric

>
>
> Sorry, should have followed-up:
>
> 2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
> while (<FILE>) {
> print;
> };
>
> Garry
>

Or maybe even:

2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
while (<FILE>) {
print;
}

Garry

[Tad McClellan]

Garry Heaton <none@none.com> wrote:

> 2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";

You should always, yes *always*, check the return value from open():

open FILE, $perl_file or die "could not open '$perl_file' $!";


--
Tad McClellan SGML consulting
[email]tadmc@augustmail.com[/email] Perl programming
Fort Worth, Texas

[Eric Schwartz]

Garry Heaton <none@none.com> writes:

> Garry Heaton wrote:

>> Sorry, should have followed-up:
>>
>> 2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
>> while (<FILE>) {
>> print;
>> };
>>
>> Garry
>>

>
> Or maybe even:
>
> 2. open FILE, "< $perl_file";
> while (<FILE>) {
> print;
> }

These are still completely different from include('file.php') in PHP.
It might not hurt to read the PHP docs to understand what include()
does, and why it's not the same thing as what you just printed above.

-=Eric
--
Come to think of it, there are already a million monkeys on a million
typewriters, and Usenet is NOTHING like Shakespeare.
-- Blair Houghton.